Why 'Tropic Thunder' shouldn't be seen

[almaty 19]

WASHINGTON (CNN) -- I am so proud of everyone who turned out to Monday's premiere of the film "Tropic Thunder" to protest its unfortunate and humiliating portrayal of people with intellectual disabilities.

Prior to the premiere, I joined a large coalition of individuals and organizations to engage in discussions with DreamWorks Studios CEO Stacey Snider and others from the studio to express our concern over the film's "Simple Jack" subplot and the slogans, "Once upon a time there was a retard," and "Never go full retard."

Members of the Coalition of National Disability Organizations -- disabled advocates and family members of people with intellectual disabilities -- have seen the movie and reported shock and disgust. Their reactions have resonated with many of us who take their cause and their voice with the utmost seriousness.

While I am disappointed that we were not consulted in the same manner as other minority groups depicted in the film and that there are 17 mentions of the "R-word" with one mention of the "N-word," I am grateful to Ms. Snider for listening to the coalition and for taking steps to eliminate some of the film's most offensive marketing elements.

I am also appreciative of her commitment to working in the future for an end to denigrating speech and hurtful portrayals of people with intellectual disabilities in film and in society. DreamWorks and its leaders have a powerful reputation for advancing socially and politically important issues.

In particular, Steven Spielberg has been a generous supporter of the work of Special Olympics, for which I am deeply grateful. I look forward to counting the hopes and dreams of 200 million people with intellectual disabilities among the causes of this formidable group of creative and artistic leaders.

Now, however, is the time to raise our voices against "Tropic Thunder" and the harm it is sure to visit on people with intellectual disabilities.

Together with the members of the international coalition, I am asking Steven Spielberg, Stacey Snider, Ben Stiller and the entire "Tropic Thunder" team to stop showing the film, and asking movie theaters and moviegoers to shut this movie out. "Tropic Thunder" is a colossal blunder. Don't show or see "Tropic Thunder."

The degrading use of the word "retard" together with the broader humiliation of people with intellectual disabilities in the film goes way too far. When the R-word is casually bandied about and when bumbling, clueless caricatures designed to mimic the behavior of people with intellectual disabilities are on screen, they have an unmistakable outcome: They mock, directly or indirectly, people with intellectual disabilities. They perpetuate the worst stereotypes. They further exclusion and isolation. They are simply mean.

Mockery in any form, or for any purpose or directed at anyone, especially those least able to defend themselves, is neither funny nor acceptable. We must work together to bring it to an end. As chairman of the Special Olympics, I am inspired to be as vocal as possible about this important matter to effect positive change and to generate support for those who deserve our respect.

Name-calling is a subtle but malicious practice that only serves to perpetuate stigma, fear, intolerance and more. iReport.com: Share your thoughts on 'Tropic Thunder'

Ridicule is a subtle but malicious practice that only serves to exclude and marginalize people with intellectual disabilities. Stop "Tropic Thunder."

People with intellectual disabilities can be great athletes, productive employees, positive friends, courageous role models. Let's open our schools, doctors offices, businesses, communities, and most importantly, our hearts to the giftedness of every human being. No more exceptions. No more exclusion.

Some may think we ought to lighten up and not get so worked up because this is, after all, just a film. But films become part of pop culture and character lines are repeated in other settings time and time again. It's clear to me that lines from this particular film will provide hurtful ammunition outside the movie theatre. While I realize that the film's creators call this a parody and they never intended to hurt anyone, it doesn't mean those words won't.

How can you help? Ban the R-word. Ban the movie. Take a stand.

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

There's also a campaign to ban smoking in movies because it encourages uptake. Personally I think its a bit silly. I'm less offended by the use of particular words (or props) than say.... thematic subtexts that reflect certain prejudices.

[pedroh 21]

oi i saw that yesterday

but robert downey jr playing an aussie actor who wants to play a black actor.. priceless

[Amby 490]

Didn't they change that Blackeyed Peas song from "lets get retarded in here" to "let's get it started in here" because they didn't want to offend anyone?

[Ilya R. 0]

Wow, what else can we ban?

[Mark&Steph 0]

Sorry, but we're gonna go see it. Maybe even twice.

[pedroh 21]

yea.. usually downey jr dont dissappoint.. and jack black and ben stiller together.. LOL

[Mononoke28 135]

The same thing happened when "There's Something About Mary" came out and the movie was a hit. It happens all the time.

Diana

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

This was actually pretty funny - worth watching for Robert Downey Jr alone.

Also Tom Cruise probably does more swearing in this than his entire acting career so far.

The "retard" stuff is mainly a lampoon on Hollywood movies like Forrest Gump and Rain Man.

[IAMX 3,055]

Sorry, but I'm not going to skip a movie (saw it last night, in fact) just because they aren't politically correct and jestingly portray a perfectly normal person as a retard in obvious hyperbole (just for the people who need a "THIS IS A JOKE" sign above the act). In fact, because it may be seen as offensive is exactly why it's funny. People make fun of George Bush being stupid, and make fun of him for maybe being closer (in looks and maybe DNA) to monkeys than the rest of us. And it's okay. But exaggerating a fictional retard isn't? Humor is the spice of life, and hurts no one.

More about the movie, it's pretty funny, and Tom Cruise looks like a friggen hobbit with those Final Fantasy 7 style giganto-hairy arms and diminutive stature. I'd recommend it to anyone. It got a very good score on Rotten Tomatoes for good reason.

Edited August 18, 2008 by SRVT

[amiquechu 0]

oi i saw that yesterday

but robert downey jr playing an aussie actor who wants to play a black actor.. priceless

Is that what that was? I saw "Downey, Jr." above the black guy in all the advertisements and was wondering if there was some new up-and-coming black actor named Something Downey, Jr.

Edited August 18, 2008 by SKTEAMO

[chuckb 0]

Darn, and I was going to complain about the show "Ugly Betty" last year. This is obviously more important.

What is this world coming to? My sister falls in the catagory of retarded. She is. So what?

Why should I worry about what other people think or say?

I find this sort of thing offensive. Why call attention to a situation that just is. We don't have a massive movement for ugly people. Please note I didn't call anyone "Ugly"...

You call attention to yourselves for what? It certainly doesn't help anything...

[Mark&Steph 0]

I don't think they're really making fun of retarded people. They're making fun of actors who portray them in movies in order to get awards or have people take them more seriously as an actor.

That was my take on it anyway.

[pedroh 21]

oi i saw that yesterday

but robert downey jr playing an aussie actor who wants to play a black actor.. priceless

Is that what that was? I saw "Downey, Jr." above the black guy in all the advertisements and was wondering if there was some new up-and-coming black actor named Something Downey, Jr.

yea he plays an aussie who goes under 'skin pigmentation' to act as a black actor.. that itself is worth watching imo

[IAMX 3,055]

oi i saw that yesterday

but robert downey jr playing an aussie actor who wants to play a black actor.. priceless

Is that what that was? I saw "Downey, Jr." above the black guy in all the advertisements and was wondering if there was some new up-and-coming black actor named Something Downey, Jr.

yea he plays an aussie who goes under 'skin pigmentation' to act as a black actor.. that itself is worth watching imo

Funny part was I had no idea it was Downey Jr (didn't pay much attention to who was acting besides reading up on the premise of the movie and seeing if it didn't have a pathetic review like the movie I had intended to see), so I was sitting there wondering for the longest time who the hell that was..