Student With History-breaking GPA denied top spot

[jundp 191]

Grapevine student with top grades won't be valedictorian

10:31 PM CDT on Wednesday, May 28, 2008

By LAURIE FOX / The Dallas Morning News

lfox@dallasnews.com

Grapevine High School senior Anjali Datta holds the highest grade point average of the 471 students graduating from Grapevine High School this year.

Anjali Datta's GPA of 5.898 may be the highest in the Grapevine High School history, but she can't be valedictorian and get a one-year scholarship from the state because she graduated in three years instead of the usual four.

View larger More photos Photo store In fact, Grapevine-Colleyville ISD officials believe her GPA of 5.898 may be the highest in the high school’s history.

It’s still not enough to make her the valedictorian, which brings a one-year college scholarship from the state.

Her closest competitor’s GPA is 5.64. No one disputes that she’s the top student in her class numerically. The problem rests with another number entirely.

Anjali rocketed through high school in only three years.

But a school district policy states: “the valedictorian shall be the eligible student with the highest weighted grade point average for four years of high school.”

The dispute over Anjali’s status as valedictorian comes down to interpretation: Does four years mean calendar years of school attendance or does it mean completing the credits it takes most students four years to earn?

It depends on whom you ask.

The 16-year-old started taking high school classes in middle school and she says her teachers encouraged her to graduate a year early because she had more than enough credits for graduation.

She said a counselor assured her that doing so wouldn’t affect her valedictorian status because she earned her four years of high school credit in the district’s schools. Officials had no comment about what a counselor may have said.

The policy was created to protect students from others who might transfer into the district close to graduation and usurp the class ranking of longtime students.

Though that’s not the situation in this case, the district’s attorneys interpreted the policy literally.

So at graduation ceremonies, 18-year-old Tyler Scott Franklin of Colleyville, will be the Grapevine High School valedictorian.

Anjali will be “Valedictorian—Three-Year.”

District officials said the title was created for this situation.

“We’re doing what we can to extend an additional honor within accordance of school board policy,” said Megan Overman, a district spokeswoman. “I’m not going to say that this has been an easy situation. This is something that is new for all of us. We’ve not faced this situation before.”

Ms. Overman said the district researched the decision for months.

“There was a lot of thought involved in this. There is no perfect answer,” she said.

Anjali says she and her parents are baffled.

“I have not heard of any educational institution penalizing a student for excellence – for completing a demanding set of classes ‘too quickly,’” said her father, Deepak Datta. “Anjali’s experience will surely send a strong negative signal to other talented students trying to excel.

“They will most certainly be discouraged from trying to do their best – instead will be more focused on gaming the system.”

On Tuesday, Grapevine High School principal Jerry Hollingsworth notified the family via e-mail of the district’s position that would arrive this week by certified letter.

“The determination of valedictory honor is one that rests squarely on Grapevine-Colleyville ISD board policy,” Dr. Hollingsworth wrote. “In determining an appropriate interpretation of our policy, inquiries were made to both the school district’s attorney as well as an attorney at the Texas Association of School Boards.

“Both were clear in their opinions that this honor should go to a student who has four school years in his or her high school career. We are compelled to adhere to school board policy,” he wrote.

So, Tyler will receive the college scholarship.

His mother, Kathy, said her family didn’t raise the issue with the school district. She said someone brought the district policy to her family’s attention.

“We feel obviously that the other student deserves recognition as well,” she said. “Considering all of the different factors, this was a good solution.”

Anjali says she’s struggling to understand the move because the Texas Education Agency doesn’t even mention the word “valedictorian” when defining eligibility for the college scholarship.

The state provides Texas high schools with an “Honor Graduate Certificate.” The certificate is to be presented to the “highest ranking graduate” in the senior class, according to Texas Education Code.

State officials say it is the local school district’s responsibility to determine the highest ranking student, and the state has no authority to get involved. At graduation on June 7, Anjali will be honored for her perfect ACT score. She will be acknowledged as an honor graduate and allowed to address her classmates.

But Anjali said it still doesn’t feel quite right.

“This really diminishes the value of the valedictorian title,” she said.

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dw...n.3b254412.html

Edited May 29, 2008 by jundp

[Amby 490]

if I was the guy that got the spot I would insist it was given to her. #######? penalties for excelling?

[felnfrank 1]

mmmm

[jundp 191]

if I was the guy that got the spot I would insist it was given to her. #######? penalties for excelling?

I agree. And she loses the scholarship, which is #######.

[almaty 19]

terrible injustice

[Nagishkaw 510]

[Bassi and Zainab 1]

I would be so pissed I would just skip graduation. She worked hard in school to get a made up title and jilted of a rightfully deserved scholarship. That sucks!

[Ban Hammer 13,964]

[Nagishkaw 510]

I would be so pissed I would just skip graduation. She worked hard in school to get a made up title and jilted of a rightfully deserved scholarship. That sucks!

...and then some.

[almaty 19]

time to call in the .....

[Illinois 0]

If this policy was followed at college level, a student who graduates in three years in college should be stripped of his/her scholarships!!

As someone involved in education, I am amazed at the idiocy of the "so-called educators" in Texas and the injustice

[Nagishkaw 510]

...and the FBI, and the CIA, the BBC, dig it, dig it.... Edited May 29, 2008 by Nagishkaw

[almaty 19]

right as always sister mocassin

[Ban Hammer 13,964]

If this policy was followed at college level, a student who graduates in three years in college should be stripped of his/her scholarships!!

As someone involved in education, I am amazed at the idiocy of the "so-called educators" in Texas and the injustice

i think they are more concerned about a lawsuit. if they gave it to the one who graduated in 3 years, they'd have been sued. while strange, i think they found the best middle ground - for the school.

“The determination of valedictory honor is one that rests squarely on Grapevine-Colleyville ISD board policy,” Dr. Hollingsworth wrote. “In determining an appropriate interpretation of our policy, inquiries were made to both the school district’s attorney as well as an attorney at the Texas Association of School Boards.

“Both were clear in their opinions that this honor should go to a student who has four school years in his or her high school career. We are compelled to adhere to school board policy,” he wrote.

[Trumplestiltskin 5,791]

It sounds like some sort of bureaucratic snafu by paper pushers adhering to mindless, arbitrary rules.