Jump to content
selby226

K-1 to K-3 Switch?

 Share

9 posts in this topic

Recommended Posts

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Canada
Timeline

Hi,

I posted this question to an old thread but then realized I should have just started a new thread! Not sure if anyone else is going through this...

I started down the path for a K-1 visa last summer, sending in the I-129F. Got it approved (finally!), and we've got our first consulate appointment in Vancouver scheduled. Culturally, we have to have a religious ceremony in my fiancee's place of residence before we're allowed to live together, but when we started we figured we could get the court marriage done in the US, apply for Advanced Parole, and then return to Canada in a reasonable amount of time to get religiously married. The problem is that AP is now taking about 4 months. We think we can show a financial hardship and try to get the AP expedited because she'd have to stay in an apartment and not with me, so I'd have 2 sets of utilities, a mortgage, plus rent for an apartment, but who really knows if that's enough of a reason to warrant an expedited AP.

We know if we get the K-1 visa, get court-married, apply for AP and then go to Canada without it, we've "abandoned" the K-1 visa and will have to re-apply under a K-3 visa. I've heard that "abandoning" a visa for another one is frowned upon by USCIS - does anyone know if that's true??

Also, does anyone know if you can switch to the K-3 visa path from K-1? And if you switched before you get your K-1 visa from the Consulate, is it technically "abandoning" it, since you never got it in the first place?

Any help is appreciated!

-Selby

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Other Country: China
Timeline
Hi,

I posted this question to an old thread but then realized I should have just started a new thread! Not sure if anyone else is going through this...

I started down the path for a K-1 visa last summer, sending in the I-129F. Got it approved (finally!), and we've got our first consulate appointment in Vancouver scheduled. Culturally, we have to have a religious ceremony in my fiancee's place of residence before we're allowed to live together, but when we started we figured we could get the court marriage done in the US, apply for Advanced Parole, and then return to Canada in a reasonable amount of time to get religiously married. The problem is that AP is now taking about 4 months. We think we can show a financial hardship and try to get the AP expedited because she'd have to stay in an apartment and not with me, so I'd have 2 sets of utilities, a mortgage, plus rent for an apartment, but who really knows if that's enough of a reason to warrant an expedited AP.

We know if we get the K-1 visa, get court-married, apply for AP and then go to Canada without it, we've "abandoned" the K-1 visa and will have to re-apply under a K-3 visa. I've heard that "abandoning" a visa for another one is frowned upon by USCIS - does anyone know if that's true??

Also, does anyone know if you can switch to the K-3 visa path from K-1? And if you switched before you get your K-1 visa from the Consulate, is it technically "abandoning" it, since you never got it in the first place?

Any help is appreciated!

-Selby

Since your legal marriage is required to be in the US anyway, why not do the non-legal ceremony before she leaves Canada?

You cannot "switch" visas. You start over again from scratch.

Edited by pushbrk

Facts are cheap...knowing how to use them is precious...
Understanding the big picture is priceless. Anonymous

Google Who is Pushbrk?

A Warning to Green Card Holders About Voting

http://www.visajourney.com/forums/topic/606646-a-warning-to-green-card-holders-about-voting/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Canada
Timeline
Hi,

I posted this question to an old thread but then realized I should have just started a new thread! Not sure if anyone else is going through this...

I started down the path for a K-1 visa last summer, sending in the I-129F. Got it approved (finally!), and we've got our first consulate appointment in Vancouver scheduled. Culturally, we have to have a religious ceremony in my fiancee's place of residence before we're allowed to live together, but when we started we figured we could get the court marriage done in the US, apply for Advanced Parole, and then return to Canada in a reasonable amount of time to get religiously married. The problem is that AP is now taking about 4 months. We think we can show a financial hardship and try to get the AP expedited because she'd have to stay in an apartment and not with me, so I'd have 2 sets of utilities, a mortgage, plus rent for an apartment, but who really knows if that's enough of a reason to warrant an expedited AP.

We know if we get the K-1 visa, get court-married, apply for AP and then go to Canada without it, we've "abandoned" the K-1 visa and will have to re-apply under a K-3 visa. I've heard that "abandoning" a visa for another one is frowned upon by USCIS - does anyone know if that's true??

Also, does anyone know if you can switch to the K-3 visa path from K-1? And if you switched before you get your K-1 visa from the Consulate, is it technically "abandoning" it, since you never got it in the first place?

Any help is appreciated!

-Selby

Since your legal marriage is required to be in the US anyway, why not do the non-legal ceremony before she leaves Canada?

You cannot "switch" visas. You start over again from scratch.

Thanks for the reply. We thought about that too - but unfortunately, we found out that in Canada, a religious ceremony constitutes a legal ceremony, so if we did that first, we'd be entering the US on a K-1 visa but already legally married.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Other Country: China
Timeline
Hi,

I posted this question to an old thread but then realized I should have just started a new thread! Not sure if anyone else is going through this...

I started down the path for a K-1 visa last summer, sending in the I-129F. Got it approved (finally!), and we've got our first consulate appointment in Vancouver scheduled. Culturally, we have to have a religious ceremony in my fiancee's place of residence before we're allowed to live together, but when we started we figured we could get the court marriage done in the US, apply for Advanced Parole, and then return to Canada in a reasonable amount of time to get religiously married. The problem is that AP is now taking about 4 months. We think we can show a financial hardship and try to get the AP expedited because she'd have to stay in an apartment and not with me, so I'd have 2 sets of utilities, a mortgage, plus rent for an apartment, but who really knows if that's enough of a reason to warrant an expedited AP.

We know if we get the K-1 visa, get court-married, apply for AP and then go to Canada without it, we've "abandoned" the K-1 visa and will have to re-apply under a K-3 visa. I've heard that "abandoning" a visa for another one is frowned upon by USCIS - does anyone know if that's true??

Also, does anyone know if you can switch to the K-3 visa path from K-1? And if you switched before you get your K-1 visa from the Consulate, is it technically "abandoning" it, since you never got it in the first place?

Any help is appreciated!

-Selby

Since your legal marriage is required to be in the US anyway, why not do the non-legal ceremony before she leaves Canada?

You cannot "switch" visas. You start over again from scratch.

Thanks for the reply. We thought about that too - but unfortunately, we found out that in Canada, a religious ceremony constitutes a legal ceremony, so if we did that first, we'd be entering the US on a K-1 visa but already legally married.

I'd double check that because if true, you would end up with two legal marriages. That's a definite bolox. In most cases, a religious ceremony can be a legal marriage but doesn't have to be. Ask the right question to make sure you get the right answer.

Facts are cheap...knowing how to use them is precious...
Understanding the big picture is priceless. Anonymous

Google Who is Pushbrk?

A Warning to Green Card Holders About Voting

http://www.visajourney.com/forums/topic/606646-a-warning-to-green-card-holders-about-voting/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Canada
Timeline
Hi,

I posted this question to an old thread but then realized I should have just started a new thread! Not sure if anyone else is going through this...

I started down the path for a K-1 visa last summer, sending in the I-129F. Got it approved (finally!), and we've got our first consulate appointment in Vancouver scheduled. Culturally, we have to have a religious ceremony in my fiancee's place of residence before we're allowed to live together, but when we started we figured we could get the court marriage done in the US, apply for Advanced Parole, and then return to Canada in a reasonable amount of time to get religiously married. The problem is that AP is now taking about 4 months. We think we can show a financial hardship and try to get the AP expedited because she'd have to stay in an apartment and not with me, so I'd have 2 sets of utilities, a mortgage, plus rent for an apartment, but who really knows if that's enough of a reason to warrant an expedited AP.

We know if we get the K-1 visa, get court-married, apply for AP and then go to Canada without it, we've "abandoned" the K-1 visa and will have to re-apply under a K-3 visa. I've heard that "abandoning" a visa for another one is frowned upon by USCIS - does anyone know if that's true??

Also, does anyone know if you can switch to the K-3 visa path from K-1? And if you switched before you get your K-1 visa from the Consulate, is it technically "abandoning" it, since you never got it in the first place?

Any help is appreciated!

-Selby

Since your legal marriage is required to be in the US anyway, why not do the non-legal ceremony before she leaves Canada?

You cannot "switch" visas. You start over again from scratch.

Thanks for the reply. We thought about that too - but unfortunately, we found out that in Canada, a religious ceremony constitutes a legal ceremony, so if we did that first, we'd be entering the US on a K-1 visa but already legally married.

I'd double check that because if true, you would end up with two legal marriages. That's a definite bolox. In most cases, a religious ceremony can be a legal marriage but doesn't have to be. Ask the right question to make sure you get the right answer.

I guess I'll have to ask the consulate when I get there. I did confirm that a religious ceremony in Canada counts as a legal marriage, but if you already have a marriage certificate from the States, they just accept a copy of it and send it on to the appropriate people (thus not having two legal marriages). But they won't do it the other way; if you do religious first, they have to fill out the marriage certificate and send it in, making it the legal marriage. The problem is just getting back to Canada if you do the legal marriage in the States. And I think you're right about having to start over if you go from a K-1 to a K-3.

Any ideas out there for what's qualified people to get an expedited advanced parole, or at least something faster than 4 months?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Other Country: China
Timeline
Hi,

I posted this question to an old thread but then realized I should have just started a new thread! Not sure if anyone else is going through this...

I started down the path for a K-1 visa last summer, sending in the I-129F. Got it approved (finally!), and we've got our first consulate appointment in Vancouver scheduled. Culturally, we have to have a religious ceremony in my fiancee's place of residence before we're allowed to live together, but when we started we figured we could get the court marriage done in the US, apply for Advanced Parole, and then return to Canada in a reasonable amount of time to get religiously married. The problem is that AP is now taking about 4 months. We think we can show a financial hardship and try to get the AP expedited because she'd have to stay in an apartment and not with me, so I'd have 2 sets of utilities, a mortgage, plus rent for an apartment, but who really knows if that's enough of a reason to warrant an expedited AP.

We know if we get the K-1 visa, get court-married, apply for AP and then go to Canada without it, we've "abandoned" the K-1 visa and will have to re-apply under a K-3 visa. I've heard that "abandoning" a visa for another one is frowned upon by USCIS - does anyone know if that's true??

Also, does anyone know if you can switch to the K-3 visa path from K-1? And if you switched before you get your K-1 visa from the Consulate, is it technically "abandoning" it, since you never got it in the first place?

Any help is appreciated!

-Selby

Since your legal marriage is required to be in the US anyway, why not do the non-legal ceremony before she leaves Canada?

You cannot "switch" visas. You start over again from scratch.

Thanks for the reply. We thought about that too - but unfortunately, we found out that in Canada, a religious ceremony constitutes a legal ceremony, so if we did that first, we'd be entering the US on a K-1 visa but already legally married.

I'd double check that because if true, you would end up with two legal marriages. That's a definite bolox. In most cases, a religious ceremony can be a legal marriage but doesn't have to be. Ask the right question to make sure you get the right answer.

I guess I'll have to ask the consulate when I get there. I did confirm that a religious ceremony in Canada counts as a legal marriage, but if you already have a marriage certificate from the States, they just accept a copy of it and send it on to the appropriate people (thus not having two legal marriages). But they won't do it the other way; if you do religious first, they have to fill out the marriage certificate and send it in, making it the legal marriage. The problem is just getting back to Canada if you do the legal marriage in the States. And I think you're right about having to start over if you go from a K-1 to a K-3.

Any ideas out there for what's qualified people to get an expedited advanced parole, or at least something faster than 4 months?

Ok, you not only asked the wrong question but you asked the wrong people. A marriage is either legal or is isn't and that is determined by the laws of the jurisdiction controling marriage in the (usually County) where the marriage took place.

You want to ask the person officiating at the religious ceremony whether it can be performed without a marriage license and officiant signature and registration with the Province etc. A "wedding ceremony" not legally and lawfully recorded and registered with the local authority and Province is not a legal marriage. It's in the paperwork. No government paperwork, no legal marriage. No legal marriage means "Not Married" to the Consulate.

Of course, if you do a not legal wedding ceremony, you don't go to any interview or present yourselves as husband and wife. You can even do the ceremony after the visa is issued and before US entry.

Again, this is a question for the ceremony officiant, not the Consulate. I don't know what the answer will be but you must ask the right question of the right person. My religion wouldn't sanction a couple living as man and wife unless they were legally married but that's one circumstance, not universal.

Facts are cheap...knowing how to use them is precious...
Understanding the big picture is priceless. Anonymous

Google Who is Pushbrk?

A Warning to Green Card Holders About Voting

http://www.visajourney.com/forums/topic/606646-a-warning-to-green-card-holders-about-voting/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Other Timeline

The marriage laws in Canada are funky, in that if a religious officiate is licensed to perform marriages, then whether or not the "legal" paperwork is processed, the couple is legally married.

The only way to have a "not legal" religious wedding ceremony in Canada is to have an officiate who is not licensed and registered to perform marriages. Which would probably mean they are also not a bonafide clergy of your preferred religion.

divorced - April 2010 moved back to Ontario May 2010 and surrendered green card

PLEASE DO NOT PRIVATE MESSAGE ME OR EMAIL ME. I HAVE NO IDEA ABOUT CURRENT US IMMIGRATION PROCEDURES!!!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: K-1 Visa Country: Canada
Timeline
The marriage laws in Canada are funky, in that if a religious officiate is licensed to perform marriages, then whether or not the "legal" paperwork is processed, the couple is legally married.

The only way to have a "not legal" religious wedding ceremony in Canada is to have an officiate who is not licensed and registered to perform marriages. Which would probably mean they are also not a bonafide clergy of your preferred religion.

Yup, that's what I saw. I did ask the right question of the right people - The church is required by law to legally record the marriage if performed by a priest or clergyman (which is also required for the church to "bless" the marriage), but if the marriage was already done legally, then they just take a copy of the legal certificate and pass it along to where-ever they need to send it. Trust me, I pleaded a few times for them to bend the rules; no luck.

I guess it also boils down to whether abandoning a K-1 visa and starting a K-3 visa hurts your chances. A couple of lawyers I spoke to said it's allowed, but they wouldn't comment on whether they make it more difficult. Or what qualifies to get expedited AP; it sounds like it's completely dependent on the mood of the person you happen to be speaking to at Immigration Services that day...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Filed: Other Country: China
Timeline
The marriage laws in Canada are funky, in that if a religious officiate is licensed to perform marriages, then whether or not the "legal" paperwork is processed, the couple is legally married.

The only way to have a "not legal" religious wedding ceremony in Canada is to have an officiate who is not licensed and registered to perform marriages. Which would probably mean they are also not a bonafide clergy of your preferred religion.

Yup, that's what I saw. I did ask the right question of the right people - The church is required by law to legally record the marriage if performed by a priest or clergyman (which is also required for the church to "bless" the marriage), but if the marriage was already done legally, then they just take a copy of the legal certificate and pass it along to where-ever they need to send it. Trust me, I pleaded a few times for them to bend the rules; no luck.

I guess it also boils down to whether abandoning a K-1 visa and starting a K-3 visa hurts your chances. A couple of lawyers I spoke to said it's allowed, but they wouldn't comment on whether they make it more difficult. Or what qualifies to get expedited AP; it sounds like it's completely dependent on the mood of the person you happen to be speaking to at Immigration Services that day...

Yeah, I think you have it boiled down well. On a more careful reading of your previous post, I see you did ask the right question in the right place. From what I've seen here, I think you have a good chance of emergency advanced parole. I've seen people get it just to take a business trip with their spouse. Starting over is not a handicap from the USCIS and DOS side except for the additional time apart. People decide to get married during the K1 process for various reasons. Life happens.

Facts are cheap...knowing how to use them is precious...
Understanding the big picture is priceless. Anonymous

Google Who is Pushbrk?

A Warning to Green Card Holders About Voting

http://www.visajourney.com/forums/topic/606646-a-warning-to-green-card-holders-about-voting/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 
Didn't find the answer you were looking for? Ask our VJ Immigration Lawyers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
- Back to Top -

Important Disclaimer: Please read carefully the Visajourney.com Terms of Service. If you do not agree to the Terms of Service you should not access or view any page (including this page) on VisaJourney.com. Answers and comments provided on Visajourney.com Forums are general information, and are not intended to substitute for informed professional medical, psychiatric, psychological, tax, legal, investment, accounting, or other professional advice. Visajourney.com does not endorse, and expressly disclaims liability for any product, manufacturer, distributor, service or service provider mentioned or any opinion expressed in answers or comments. VisaJourney.com does not condone immigration fraud in any way, shape or manner. VisaJourney.com recommends that if any member or user knows directly of someone involved in fraudulent or illegal activity, that they report such activity directly to the Department of Homeland Security, Immigration and Customs Enforcement. You can contact ICE via email at Immigration.Reply@dhs.gov or you can telephone ICE at 1-866-347-2423. All reported threads/posts containing reference to immigration fraud or illegal activities will be removed from this board. If you feel that you have found inappropriate content, please let us know by contacting us here with a url link to that content. Thank you.
×
×
  • Create New...