American Idol 2008

[Mary Lou 681]

I really liked what Brooke did with her song tonight

Cant deny Carly has the voice, but just cant seem to warm up to her at all.

I was shocked i liked Amanda tonight.

I still feel the women arent as good as the men, i was disappointed tonight overall.

####### was with Paula tonight ???????

[Frank+Jocelyn 1]

####### was with Paula tonight ???????

She was very anoying. I wonder if she was high on something

[Cassie 8]

My top three:

Amanda Overmeyer -- excellent, excellent, excellent -- perfect song for her

Carly Smithson -- great voice, not a big fan of the song she picked, but she's strong

Brooke White -- loved the arrangement with the acoustic guitar, very nice! Liking her more and more each week

Honestly, I really think Paula was on something this week -- very few complete sentences with recognizable words came out of her mouth.

[Mary Lou 681]

My top three:

Amanda Overmeyer -- excellent, excellent, excellent -- perfect song for her

Carly Smithson -- great voice, not a big fan of the song she picked, but she's strong

Brooke White -- loved the arrangement with the acoustic guitar, very nice! Liking her more and more each week

Honestly, I really think Paula was on something this week -- very few complete sentences with recognizable words came out of her mouth.

Paula spouts such rubbish usually anyway, but tonight was worse.

[Jenn! 918]

I'm fully convinced now that Randy doesn't know what the hell he's talking about. Kady Malloy's big notes were noticeably flat, and he said they were good, not mentioning a thing about being 'pitchy'.

Anyway, I liked Carly best. I'm not sure what kind of songs they want her to sing either - I think her choices both last week and this week were good.

I didn't get Amanda's performance at all.

The other performances I'm having trouble remembering. I think very few people should even attempt Whitney, and

Syesha and A'siah are not them.

Ramiele's performance I spaced out about half way through so that can't be a good sign. I don't even know what the judges said.

I would like to see Kady and Kristy gone tomorrow.

[morocco4ever 63]

####### was with Paula tonight ???????

She was very anoying. I wonder if she was high on something

I have noticed that she starts out normal, but by the end of the show she is pretty loopy. I can't help but wonder what really is in her coke cup!

I'm fully convinced now that Randy doesn't know what the hell he's talking about. Kady Malloy's big notes were noticeably flat, and he said they were good, not mentioning a thing about being 'pitchy'.

Anyway, I liked Carly best. I'm not sure what kind of songs they want her to sing either - I think her choices both last week and this week were good.

I didn't get Amanda's performance at all.

The other performances I'm having trouble remembering. I think very few people should even attempt Whitney, and

Syesha and A'siah are not them.

Ramiele's performance I spaced out about half way through so that can't be a good sign. I don't even know what the judges said.

I would like to see Kady and Kristy gone tomorrow.

I agree, Kady and Kristy should go.

I also agree, Carly is the best singer by far. Amanda, I had to laugh. Just last week, when her performance totally sucked, I told my sister that I think she should do a Joan Jett song. Hah...I was right! She blew it away. Not that I think she should win, but it was a big improvement. I was a little stunned by her fiance in the audience...he seemed so.....normal.

[eau_xplain 2]

I love watching the contestants' faces whenever Paula talks.

[sereia 0]

i agree with kady and kristy being the two to go! buh byeeeeeee!

[keltic 1]

its nice to see blake

[eau_xplain 2]

Here we go. Guys are up!

Edited March 7, 2008 by eau_xplain

[Zee Bee 61]

Bye bye Kady Malloy.

[~Jackie~ 30]

I'm stuck at work.

jJ

[Zee Bee 61]

Bye bye Luke Menard.

[Jenn! 918]

Where are Paula's Merry Men?

[~Jackie~ 30]

What am i missing?

jj