American Idol 2008

[a-jeanne 2]

Did anyone else notice the dirty looks and faces Kady was making when the judges were talking about her performance. If looks could kill, Simon would be dead lol She reminded me of that contestant Antonella, (the one who had the racy photos posted online of her) from last year. She rolled her eyes and made faces when the judges spoke too.

I saw it - I thought it was very inappropriate. She should go - good voice or no.

Also, have you noticed how Ryan has given Simon a hard time and doesn't even recognize him at the end of the show as a judge. How RUDE! I'm a bit disappointed in the whole thing really.

[Autumnchik 6]

I have to say, I wasn't really wowed by anyone last night. I even drank 2 glasses of wine in an attempt to muster some alcohol induced enthusiasm. It didn't work.

I'm feeling the same way so far. I liked Asia'h, Ramiele and Carly, but that's all it was: like .... no strong pull to root for anyone yet. I like the concept of Amanda, rock and roll and all that, but think that she needs to change things up a little.

And did anyone notice that Paula has already started to pull the "you look beautiful" card whenever someone sucks at singing??!!

[Zee Bee 61]

I'm feeling the same way so far. I liked Asia'h, Ramiele and Carly, but that's all it was: like .... no strong pull to root for anyone yet. I like the concept of Amanda, rock and roll and all that, but think that she needs to change things up a little.

And did anyone notice that Paula has already started to pull the "you look beautiful" card whenever someone sucks at singing??!!

I thought that was just me.

So far this season has been a disappointment.

[doodlebugg 10]

WOW I'm in SHOCK!!

I really really thought Amanda had HUGE potential!!!

[Jenn! 918]

WOW I'm in SHOCK!!

I really really thought Amanda had HUGE potential!!!

huh?

[Kazan' Tiger 1]

100& agree with the boots tonight. They kicked the bottom four out I would have.

[doodlebugg 10]

WOW I'm in SHOCK!!

I really really thought Amanda had HUGE potential!!!

huh?

maybe i need to have my ears examined.

[Zee Bee 61]

They got it right with Colton, Amanda and Garrett.

Joanne should have stayed.

Kristy should have gone home.

[doodlebugg 10]

They got it right with Colton, Amanda and Garrett.

Joanne should have stayed.

Kristy should have gone home.

you mean amy, not amanda right? I keep getting amanda mixed up with joanne. joanne definitely should have stayed!!

[Zee Bee 61]

They got it right with Colton, Amanda and Garrett.

Joanne should have stayed.

Kristy should have gone home.

you mean amy, not amanda right? I keep getting amanda mixed up with joanne. joanne definitely should have stayed!!

Whoops...Amy.

[Mary Lou 681]

Yeah, i agree Joanne should have stayed.

No one has WOWED me yet this season.

Theres something about Carly i dont like, not sure what it is yet, but she does have a good voice.

The Ryan and Simon thing is getting a bit old already and its only the beginning of the season more or less.

[Kazan' Tiger 1]

I agree regarding Carly. Its like she's hiding something. Like I can't trust her. It's silly but its how I feel when I see her.

Yeah, i agree Joanne should have stayed.

No one has WOWED me yet this season.

Theres something about Carly i dont like, not sure what it is yet, but she does have a good voice.

The Ryan and Simon thing is getting a bit old already and its only the beginning of the season more or less.

[Mary Lou 681]

I agree regarding Carly. Its like she's hiding something. Like I can't trust her. It's silly but its how I feel when I see her.

Yeah, i agree Joanne should have stayed.

No one has WOWED me yet this season.

Theres something about Carly i dont like, not sure what it is yet, but she does have a good voice.

The Ryan and Simon thing is getting a bit old already and its only the beginning of the season more or less.

Yep, i know what you mean. I'm sure time will tell.

Edited February 22, 2008 by garyandmarylou

[sparkofcreation 0]

Current favorites:

Guys:

1. David Archuleta

2. David Hernández

3. Luke Menard (thought what he did with that song on Tuesday was *awesome*)

Girls:

1. Ramiele Malubay

2. Syesha Mercardo

3. Carly Smithson.

I think the issue with Carly is that the producers are really pushing her--remember Constantine? It reminds me of the hype around him. But she can actually sing, so *she* doesn't annoy me that much, although the hype does.

I would also have kept Joanne and lost Amanda. She's interesting, but she doesn't seem interested in stepping outside hard-rock screaming into actual singing. But there are a lot of girls who are way better than Joanne (Ramiele, Syesha, Carly, Asiah, Alexandréa, even Brooke) so I don't mind *too* much that she went home.

[Jenn! 918]

EW's Revised "Power List"

'American Idol' Power List: Rating the Final 20

David Archuleta retains his position as Michael Slezak's No. 1, Jason Castro comes out of nowhere to nip at his heels, and Chikezie and Kristy Lee Cook tumble out of the Power List top 10 all the way to the bottom four

1. David Archuleta

Cuddly former Star Search winner destroyed the competition in our latest reader poll, and his rock-solid performance of ''Shop Around'' last week only cemented his front-runner status. One potential weakness at this point might be a whiff of false modesty. We know you know you're good, kiddo! (Last week's Power Ranking: No.1)

2. Jason Castro

How do you go from invisible contestant with no pre-semifinal airtime to the week's buzz-worthiest hopeful? By taking the stage with your guitar and delivering a sweet, understated take on the Lovin' Spoonful hit ''Daydream,'' then showcasing a delightfully hippie vibe in your post-performance interview. (New this week)

3. Asia'h Epperson

Wowed the judges with her first live performance — a bubbly, soulful take on Janis Joplin's ''Piece of My Heart'' — and stole the spotlight again during Thursday's otherwise woeful group medley. Certainly looks the part of an Idol, and if she can improve her diction, she's a threat to go all the way. (Last week: No.4)

4. Amanda Overmyer

''Rock & roll nurse'' delivered a gin-soaked take on ''Baby Please Don't Go,'' establishing herself as the antidote to the scads of Disney-esque teens in this year's top 20. Still, that results-show fake-out suggesting she might be in the bottom three was scary, and questions remain about the depth of her vocal talent. (Last week: No. 2)

5. Michael Johns

Choosing to repeat his Hollywood-week song choice, the Doors' ''Light My Fire,'' struck us as highly unimaginative, but there's no denying the Australian rocker has a potent voice and a polished, sexy stage presence. He's already a lock for the top 12, but he can't afford to play it safe as the competition heats up. (Last week: No. 3)

6. Ramiele Malubay

The judges went bananas over her cover of ''You Don't Have to Say You Love Me,'' and indeed, it was refreshing to hear an R&B diva show some restraint on the Idol stage. Still, we need her to prove she's more than just a great karaoke artist, and seriously upgrade her fashion choices, in the next couple weeks. (Last week: No. 11)

7. Carly Smithson

News of her MCA solo release a few years back dominated Idol headlines all week, but she got the focus back on her powerful vocals on Wednesday. Too bad her ''Shadow of Your Smile'' came off so dated and dreary, proving the importance of song choice in the competition. (Last week: No. 6)

8. Robbie Carrico

All the leather cuffs in the world won't convince us that deep down, this former boy-bander isn't more A.C. than AC/DC. That said, his on-key, emotionally connected performance of ''One'' on Tuesday night was one of the week's nicest surprises. Looking forward to seeing what else is under his head kerchief. (Last week: No. 18)

9. Alexandréa Lushington

Her version of ''Spinning Wheel'' was the week's most polarizing performance. Randy and Paula loved it; Simon loathed it. For once, though, we're siding with Paundy. To us, Alexandréa's jazzy, inventive delivery (and wicked falsetto) proved she's got a shot to outlast some of her more hyped foes. (Last week: No. 12)

10. Alaina Whitaker

Carrie Underwood look-alike flew under the radar for Idol's first five weeks, which made it all the more unexpected when she nailed ''More Today Than Yesterday'' with a confidence beyond her 16 years (and 364 days). This week should tell if she's the female answer to Archuleta, or a one-week sensation. (Last week: No. 17)

11. Syesha Mercado

Her ''Tobacco Road'' last week dialed back the full-throttle shouting that made her audition and Hollywood Week performances such a chore, but she flashed just a hint of stank attitude when explaining to Ryan how she tried to avoid flu-infected competitors. Needs to show some warmth, especially when she's not singing. (Last week: No. 15)

12. David Hernandez

His voice was on-point as usual covering ''In the Midnight Hour'' on Tuesday; unfortunately, all the passion and soul of his Hollywood Week cover of ''Love the One You're With'' was missing. Gets a pass, seeing how he was the first semifinalist to perform this season, but needs major improvement next week. (Last week: No. 9)

13. Danny Noriega

Snap-tastic teenager got slammed by Simon for his breezy take on ''Jailhouse Rock,'' but cracked up the notoriously cranky judge with his saucy comebacks. Still, to paraphrase Elvis, we'd like to see a little less conversation and a little more action the next time Danny takes the stage. He's got the voice; why not use it? (Last week: No. 13)

14. Brooke White

The G-rated nanny has built a fan base by playing up the tender folksiness both in her vocal performances and her interview packages. But considering her reedy instrument pales next to her big-voiced rivals', she'll need to deliver far more inventive arrangements than that middling karaoke cover of ''Happy Together.'' (Last week: No. 14)

15. David Cook

Simon predicted this season's resident rocker dude might be vulnerable once he puts down the guitar — and indeed, David's emo-lite take on ''Happy Together'' was hampered by pitch problems. Still, if he keeps taking risks with song arrangement, and gets some help with his jank hairdo, he could be a top 12 threat. (Last week: No. 5)

16. Kady Malloy

Got brutalized by the judges after a somnambulant rendition of ''Groovy Kind of Love,'' and her crabby demeanor in the face of a tough critique probably didn't help her. There was a nice tone hidden in the pitchy mix, but it's troubling that she's still best known for her wicked Britney Spears impersonation. (Last week: No. 10)

17. Luke Menard

A mellow-bordering-on-dull rendition of ''Everybody's Talkin''' wasn't the blazing first-impression the 29-year-old needed after getting blanked for airtime during Idol's first five weeks. Lucky for him a pleasant timbre and a resemblance to Orlando Bloom and Matthew Fox helped him survive the week. (Last week: No. 16)

18. Chikezie

Dropped his super-cool last name between Hollywood Week and the semifinals, and most of his vocal prowess seemed to go with it. Indeed, his ''More Today Than Yesterday'' was both flat and dated, and whether or not you agreed with Simon that his orange suit was a faux pas, defensive snapbacks are never in style. (Last week: No. 8)

19. Kristy Lee Cook

Audition-round front-runner may have been battling a flu bug, but her soulless rendition of ''Rescue Me'' — complete with bizarre, crazy-eyed facial expressions — didn't sound (or look) like the performance of a future Idol champ. We've only heard her nail ''Amazing Grace'' to date; is she a one-hit wonder? (Last week: No. 7)

20. Jason Yeager

Fun fact: Paula noted after Jason's performance of ''Moon River'' that her first ballet recital was set to the same classic ballad. Hey, we're trying out the ''if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all'' philosophy for a minute here. Yeah, okay, it's totally not working. (New this week)

Source