Fraud Waiver?

[diesel1 0]

His statement would not be binding, as it was just his opinion...only the decision of the court is binding. You really need a good immigration attorney....board certified.

It wasn't his personal opinion, but his opinion as an INS representative. What do you mean by a board-certified lawuer?

[diadromous mermaid 36]

His statement would not be binding, as it was just his opinion...only the decision of the court is binding. You really need a good immigration attorney....board certified.

It wasn't his personal opinion, but his opinion as an INS representative. What do you mean by a board-certified lawuer?

http://www.aila.org

[emt103c 10]

The statement in question was actually made by your ex-wife right??

The last statement just means, when you get an attorney, make sure you get a specialist. All of this will actually rest on whether or not they documented the claim of citizenship as from you or from your ex-wife. If not, there is almost nothing ANY attorney can do.

This is a sad situation. immigrate2us.net would be a good place to go, there are attorney recommmendations there too...Best of luck

[Boiler 45,522]

I am just wondering how your Mother etc are going to show Extreme Hardship.

The Visitor aspect is a B Visa and a I-192, that would give you an idea about the Citizenship claim.

[athena_ny 1]

I am just wondering how your Mother etc are going to show Extreme Hardship.

The Visitor aspect is a B Visa and a I-192, that would give you an idea about the Citizenship claim.

I am as well. Other than "missing my son", I don't see it. In a spousal situation, the hardship claim is a lot stronger, considering one would have to move, may not knowing the language, may not have much earning potential, etc etc. But an adult, divorced son? Not so much.

[diesel1 0]

The Visitor aspect is a B Visa and a I-192, that would give you an idea about the Citizenship claim.

I didn't quite get that. Do you propose that I first apply for an I-192 to find out about the citizenship claim??

[diesel1 0]

The statement in question was actually made by your ex-wife right??

The last statement just means, when you get an attorney, make sure you get a specialist. All of this will actually rest on whether or not they documented the claim of citizenship as from you or from your ex-wife. If not, there is almost nothing ANY attorney can do.

This is a sad situation. immigrate2us.net would be a good place to go, there are attorney recommmendations there too...Best of luck

Thanks! We are now trying to find out how they documented it - we have sent a FOIA request to get the file from the POE.

P.S. Did you see the 3 documents in my OP? - what do you think?

[emt103c 10]

P.S. Did you see the 3 documents in my OP? - what do you think?

I'm sorry, I think it looks bad.

[Boiler 45,522]

The Visitor aspect is a B Visa and a I-192, that would give you an idea about the Citizenship claim.

I didn't quite get that. Do you propose that I first apply for an I-192 to find out about the citizenship claim??

Should be a lot quicker than a FOIA.

[blueblue 0]

Based on the 3 documents you posted, it seems there is some basis for the false claim charge. The first page pretty clearly states that they say you claimed to be a US citizen. The 3rd page is somewhat unclear without the other context, but implies that claim.

I think it will be important to see what the FOIA says, if you can get something from the border that is different than the 1st page.

For the record, if you had claimed to only be a NATIONAL, that is NOT the same as claiming to be a citizen and would not result in the same consequences - no waiver. There is a recent court case on this related to the I-9.

Unless the FOIA provides some evidence to counter that false claim charge, I think there is not much hope until the law changes.

On that point, you can visit www.americanfamiliesunited.org. One of the provisions that group is working on is a change on this specific issue.